Announcement Module
No announcement yet.

Vezina C55 Altered and Regraded by PSA?

Page Title Module
Move Remove Collapse
Conversation Detail Module
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Vezina C55 Altered and Regraded by PSA?

    Is this not the same card?



  • #2
    That scratch over his left eye is quite telling.

    But it's in a PSA holder, so it must be good. You're questioning PSA?

    Where's that card PSA graded, the Gretzky / McNall Wagner that was trimmed?


    • #3
      Yes, this is definitely the same card - nice catch, Anish.

      It's obvious that this card got cleaned using some kind of solution, but it did end up doing some damage. Yes, the PSA 4 does have whiter borders, but look what cleaning it did to the blue background. Also, the little design found on the top left and right corners (on top of the sticks) has faded to the point where they can hardly be seen.

      Now you guys do remember what PSA did about the WWG Joe DiMaggio card, right? I don't know if it is still inside the PSA holder, but they did remove it from the registry. The thing is, the DiMaggio card was pretty expensive (and more popular too). If somebody were to bring this card to their attention, would they take the same kind of action or just let it slide?